Comments on: Watch Kindred Part 2 Tonight!

By: ltsheppard

ltsheppard — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 19:50:14 +0000

calm down folks ^^ i’ve seen the episode now too and i found it wonderful … i don’t know what yout hate about carson … maybe he is real, because that was not excluded, just stated by keller ^^ … furthermore the way rodney described carson’s death to carson (wow ) sounded like he himself thought he would be the real one …

By: Felicity

Felicity — Tue, 25 Mar 2008 02:01:20 +0000

I WANT THE REAL CARSON BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! they could have said that the one that got blown up was a clone and the real Carson is being held by Michael.

By: liquid

liquid — Tue, 11 Mar 2008 12:01:12 +0000

there are so many possibilities to save the story (fe. finding out that carson who died was a clone too and the real carson is still imprisoned out there)

I was pissed when he died, not only because the episode appeared to be somehow stupid (a strange disease that lets people explode? c’mon…).
It seemed like the episode was written especially to kick out carson.

but i totally agree with you: Clone carson is not a quality replacement for real carson. allthough clone-carson is far better than no carson

By: Donna UK

Donna UK — Fri, 07 Mar 2008 16:47:44 +0000

Carson…? Clone …? I don’t care, I was just looking at Paul :>)))

What a difference though? The whole episode seemed to come alive with him around. He’s so real. And to have the Carson / Rodney banter going again, Jeepers, I’ve missed that.

So, we’re left with a Star Wars 2 style cliff hanger. Come on Mr M, we need more than five eposides to look forward to!

By: Ellie

Ellie — Wed, 05 Mar 2008 18:44:14 +0000

Have now seen Kindred 2 and I loved it. I really don’t care if he is a clone. This is Carson in the flesh, not a dream, or flashbacks. It was great to Paul back on screen and Carson back on Atlantis. It had me tearing up again. I am writing my next batch of letters now asking for more than five episodes in series 5. Welcome back Paul!!!

By: Ben

Ben — Tue, 04 Mar 2008 21:20:43 +0000

i garuntee teylas babies father is really carson…… trust me

By: Aelfgyfu

Aelfgyfu — Tue, 04 Mar 2008 00:24:09 +0000

I’m thrilled to have Carson back, and I agree with Rodney: he’s Carson in every way that counts. I thought “The Kindred Part 2″ was wonderful in terms of the Carson plot (not the Teyla plot); I loved the scenes with Carson and Rodney especially, but also Carson and Keller (who has really grown on me), Carson and John, and even Carson and Ronon (“This is exactly what I was afraid of.”) He has Carson’s memories up through “Misbegotten,” and he certainly has Carson’s personality–and heart.

Looking forward to season 5!

By: Ellie

Ellie — Mon, 03 Mar 2008 21:06:55 +0000

You know I haven’t seen Kindred 2 yet as I live in the UK so I can only comment on what has been written above but to be honest with you I don’t understand what the fuss about Carson being a clone is all about. Let’s face it what we wanted was for him not to have died in the first place but he did and now we have to accept a “viable storyline” for his return unless we want him to come back in the shower like Bobby Ewing! I am sure if we all support Carson’s clone and lobby tptb we will have more chance of seeing his full time return than if we run the whole storyline down. Who knows how the story will develop and one thing I have learnt about being part of this campaign is not to lose heart, be patient but adamant and keep fighting. I guess what we all really wanted is the real Carson but hey maybe it is him. I seem to remember an episode a while ago when someone said everyone on Atlantis seemed to be acting differently since they returned from a mission, maybe they are all clones – who knows – let the story develop we may get exactly what we want. Come on guys be positive, I am sure we will get a much more favourable response if we are supportive and demanding rather than negative and demanding. In the meantime, I am counting the hours until tomorrow and looking forward to seeing Carson/Paul once again.

By: Jcharm

Jcharm — Mon, 03 Mar 2008 17:53:02 +0000

Kindred Pt2 made for some interesting story telling. I don’t feel that the producers explanation that it would be the “Real” Carson who would return didn’t ring true at all. Unless we’re being misdirected for some dramatic effect then the whole he’ll be back in the flesh routine was nothing but a tapestry of lies. So Dr. Beckett will be in five episodes, that one fourth of a season more than enough time to write the good doctor out of his dilemma. If not we will end up with plot points of the Atlantis crew standing outside Carson’s stasis chamber saying things like…”I wish there was more we could do for him”…As I stated before the Pegasus galaxy is a very big place and there is plenty of room for two doctors on this series, it would allow for greater and more varied story telling. This would be good for the writers, the producers and the viewers.

By: Isto

Isto — Mon, 03 Mar 2008 16:36:37 +0000

I was a bit disappointed because it is not the real Carson. It is the Carson in the flesh, but only a clone. Damn. But I am happy about having a clone back in action instead of having no Beckett there.